Richard Lee
2007-06-29 08:48:13 UTC
IMHO, practical RFI performance (as opposed to meeting EU specs) is one of the major factors that separate the good from the great mikes.
The only thing I can say is that the guys who made the recommendation were practitioners, not just theorists, being both designers of instrumentationand nerve cells and also people who were running a commercial EMC testing
facility. Mot sure if they ever did any mic designs, tho' ;-)
Once upon a time, before the days of EC RFI standards, there was the Calrec CB radio, an electric motor driving a car coil, distributor and spark plug which sparked every second with a 1m aerial on top.
Everyone hated when I started it up, cos every meter at Calrec would do a blip blip blip including (I'm told) all the passive multimeters so I could only test RFI at night. Pity TV reception in Hebden Bridge.
We got back a VERY dented Calrec stick mike from BBC Manchester with a note that it seemed very prone to lighting buzz. I opened it up and found the earth connection to the case was cracked; not surprisingly really. Since it was Saturday, I could fire up the Calrec CB radio and played around a bit ending up with 2 extra ceramic caps and slightly different earth connection.
I sent the dented souped up mike back with a letter saying we had done a full investigation and proposed modification for an exorbitant sum. About half the cost of a new mike for 10min work to move the earth and 2 caps.
The next thing, a small crate arrives by courier with some 200 mikes, the complete BBC spare inventory of Calrec mikes for the North of England and all the mikes from Manchester. Then an irate phone call asking why we hadn't done them and they had to all come back by Fri cos they were the only mikes of any make which didn't buzz in their new TV studio.
Wharfedale had some HiFi stuff tested at the York University EMI centre in the early EC standard days and found the gurus there very competent. But thyristor stage lighting in dem days required much more than meeting the EC RFI standards. I haven't tested old Calrec mikes with mobile phones but I'd be surprised if there was a problem.